Nottingham Forest 3-1 Man City Player Ratings: Delap Stars as Haaland Fails to Fire
- Primary Signal: Nottingham Forest 3-1 Man City Player Ratings: Delap Stars as Haaland Fails to Fire
- Overview: Nottingham Forest stunned Manchester City 3-1 at the City Ground, handing the champions a third straight Premier League defeat. Here are our player ratings from a famous Forest win...
- Verification: Analyzed and compiled by Soccer2026 LiveWire editorial monitoring desk.
Manchester City's title aspirations suffered a severe setback on Saturday as they slumped to a third straight Premier League defeat, conceding twice in the first half before losing 3-1 to Nottingham Forest. The result leaves City six points behind leaders Arsenal, and the champions looked a shadow of the side that has dominated English football in recent years.
Forest, by contrast, were superb. They pressed with discipline, attacked with pace and took their chances clinically. Here is how every player rated in a memorable afternoon at the City Ground.
Nottingham Forest: The Stars of the Show
Liam Delap was the standout performer, earning a 8.9 rating after a display full of power and intelligence. The striker led the line superbly, holding the ball up under pressure and finishing with real composure. His movement dragged City's defenders out of position all afternoon, and his goal was the reward his performance deserved.
Matheus Cunha also impressed with an 8.1 rating, linking play cleverly and carrying the ball through midfield whenever Forest broke forward. Morgan Gibbs-White earned 7.8 for his creativity and work rate, while goalkeeper Matz Sels (7.2) made the saves that mattered when City finally threatened. In midfield, Schlager's 7.5 reflected a disciplined display that gave City's playmakers no room to breathe.
Manchester City: A Collective Failure
City's ratings tell the story of a team badly out of sorts. Erling Haaland, the Premier League's top scorer, managed only a 5.2 after a frustrating afternoon in which he was starved of service and well marshalled by Forest's centre-backs. It was one of his quietest games of the season, and City had no answer when their main weapon was neutralised.
The defence was worse. Josko Gvardiol scored just 3.0, Ruben Dias 4.1 and Marc Guehi 4.0, as Forest cut through them with alarming ease. Gianluigi Donnarumma could do little about the goals and earned 6.1, while Rayan Cherki's 6.3 was the best of a poor midfield showing. Jeremy Doku (5.1) and the rest of the attack offered flashes but no sustained threat.
The Tactical Story
Forest's game plan was simple and brilliantly executed. They sat in a compact shape, forced City wide, and then broke at speed through Cunha and Gibbs-White whenever they won the ball. City's high line was exposed repeatedly, and the two first-half goals forced Pep Guardiola's side to chase the game from a position they never recovered from.
The second half followed a similar pattern. City had more of the ball but created little of note, and Forest's third goal killed the contest. It was a reminder that possession without penetration counts for very little against a well-organised side with a clear plan.
The Full Ratings in Brief
Nottingham Forest: Sels 7.2, Cunha 8.1, Milenkovic 6.9, Murillo 6.9, Munoz 6.5, Yates 6.6, Schlager 7.5, Williams 7.0, McAtee 6.6, Gibbs-White 7.8, Delap 8.9. Manchester City: Donnarumma 6.1, Khusanov 5.4, Dias 4.1, Guehi 4.0, Gvardiol 3.0, Anderson 5.2, Fernandez 5.1, Ndiaye 5.2, Cherki 6.3, Doku 5.1, Haaland 5.2. The gap between the two teams' ratings tells the whole story: Forest's players almost all hit their level, while City's back line had a day to forget and their attack never got going.
The Bigger Picture for Both Clubs
For Forest, the win is about more than three points. It proves their system works against the very best, and it gives the squad belief that their home ground can be a fortress all season. For City, the defeat raises serious questions. Three straight losses is their worst run in years, and the defence that once looked impregnable is conceding goals from basic errors. Guardiola has fixed crises before, but this one needs fixing fast, because Arsenal are not waiting around at the top of the table.
What It Means for the Title Race
Three straight defeats is a crisis by Manchester City's standards, and the six-point gap to Arsenal already looks significant in November. The champions have the quality to recover, but they need to fix a defence that is conceding soft goals and an attack that looks over-reliant on Haaland.
For Forest, this was a statement win. Beating the champions in this manner shows they belong in the conversation for European football, and their home form is becoming a real weapon. If they keep playing like this at the City Ground, few teams will enjoy visiting Nottingham this season.